Hearing your mechanic say your car is not worth fixing catches most owners off guard. It got you to the workshop, and now the proposed repair seems hard to justify. If this has happened to you in Perth, you have four main options: seek a second opinion, repair it anyway, sell it privately or trade it in, or sell it for dismantling and recycling.
The best choice depends on what has failed, what the rest of the car is like and how urgently you need reliable transport. Buyers of mechanically broken cars offer an alternative when repairing yours no longer makes sense, but get a clear diagnosis before deciding.
What Does “Not Worth Fixing” Actually Mean?
Mechanics usually reach this conclusion by comparing the repair quote with the car’s likely value once repaired. It does not automatically mean the vehicle is beyond repair. An expensive gearbox replacement might be possible, yet difficult to justify on a car that also needs tyres, suspension work and attention to an oil leak.
Ask whether the verdict is about cost, safety or uncertainty over further faults. Those are different problems. A car that still starts may be unsafe to drive, while a non-starting car may have one identifiable fault. Ask the workshop whether it can safely be driven or needs towing.
Parts availability also matters. With an older Jeep model, for example, ask which engine or transmission is fitted, whether suitable replacement parts are available and what warranty comes with the proposed work. Apply the same questions to any make rather than assuming every vehicle with that badge has the same prospects.

Your Main Options From Here
1. Get a second quote, then decide whether to repair
A second opinion is reasonable for a major engine or transmission job, especially if the first diagnosis is unclear. Request an itemised quote showing parts, labour, diagnosis and any work excluded from the total. Ask whether a reconditioned component is suitable and what happens if dismantling reveals more damage.
Compare the likely cost of keeping this car reliable with replacing it, rather than looking only at its resale value. A known car with a sound service history may still suit you after one repair. Repeated failures and several overdue jobs change that calculation.
If the problem is a pattern rather than one isolated bill, the signs of repairable life ending can help you assess the wider condition. This decision is about your next step after a diagnosis, rather than treating age alone as a reason to give up.
2. Sell it privately
An as-is sale may suit a buyer with the tools and experience to repair it. Describe the symptoms and known faults accurately, keep the mechanic’s report available and make collection arrangements clear. Compare realistic offers after advertising time, towing and any workshop storage charges, rather than assuming the asking price is what you will receive.
Access can change the collection plan. If the vehicle is on a driveway in Bicton, for example, explain whether it rolls, steers and has accessible wheels, and mention narrow gates or a steep approach. These details help the operator choose suitable equipment; the suburb alone does not explain the job.
3. Trade it in
If you are replacing the car, ask whether a dealer will accept it in its current condition. Compare the whole replacement deal, including any discount you would receive without a trade-in. A convenient handover can be valuable, but a generous-looking trade allowance does not tell you the total cost.
4. Sell it for dismantling or recycling
This can suit a car whose usable parts and metal have value but whose repair no longer fits your needs. Give each buyer the same condition details and ask whether collection is included. Confirm any conditions attached to the offer before accepting.
Compare the Offers Before Committing
Make and model, completeness, usable components and metal prices can all affect a dismantling offer. A non-running engine does not make every other component worthless. Equally, removing parts before sale can change an offer, so describe the car as it will actually be collected.
Keep the repair quote, private-sale estimate and collection offer separate. Subtract transport and storage costs where they apply. Ask the workshop about release arrangements before booking collection, and agree the payment method and handover timing with the buyer. Avoid authorising more work simply because you have already spent money on diagnosis.

If You’ve Decided the Repair Isn’t Worth It
You do not need to decide while standing at the workshop counter. Get the diagnosis in writing, set a deadline for comparing realistic alternatives and choose the option that leaves you with a workable transport plan. A mechanic’s cost assessment is useful evidence, rather than a command to sell immediately.
If collection would help, Cash for Cars Perth’s non-driving vehicle collection service explains the next step; you can discuss your car on 0420 262 651.
A Few Common Questions
Should I always get a second opinion?
It is especially useful when the proposed work is substantial or the diagnosis is uncertain. Ask whether a second workshop can review the report first, so you understand any further diagnosis or transport costs.
Does “not worth fixing” mean the car is written off?
No. A mechanic’s opinion about repair costs does not, by itself, establish the vehicle’s recorded write-off status. WA distinguishes statutory and repairable write-offs; check the vehicle’s status separately if that is relevant to your decision.
What if the car does not start?
Tell prospective buyers before agreeing to a sale. Confirm who will arrange transport and whether the vehicle can roll and steer. Do not assume it can be driven simply because it started earlier.





























